Select Page

The Financial Burden of the Department of Energy’s July 14th 2012 Ban on inefficient Fluorescent Tubes impacts American Businesses, Homeowners, Governors, and Mayors across the whole country. See CASH for CLUNKERS Lighting  for information on the multi-million dollar incentive program.

 

Population Percentage Burden of the Ban
United States of America (By Population) 311,000,000 100% $18,750,000,000
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
California 37,253,956 11.98% $2,246,018,248
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Texas 25,145,561 8.09% $1,516,010,510
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
New York 19,378,102 6.23% $1,168,293,931
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Florida 18,801,310 6.05% $1,133,519,494
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Illinois 12,830,632 4.13% $773,550,965
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Pennsylvania 12,702,379 4.08% $765,818,670
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Ohio 11,536,504 3.71% $695,528,778
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Michigan 9,883,640 3.18% $595,878,617
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Georgia 9,687,653 3.12% $584,062,681
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
North Carolina 9,535,483 3.07% $574,888,445
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
New Jersey 8,791,894 2.83% $530,057,918
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Virginia 8,001,024 2.57% $482,376,849
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Washington 6,724,540 2.16% $405,418,408
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Massachusetts 6,547,629 2.11% $394,752,552
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Indiana 6,483,802 2.08% $390,904,461
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Arizona 6,392,017 2.06% $385,370,800
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Tennessee 6,346,105 2.04% $382,602,793
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Missouri 5,988,927 1.93% $361,068,750
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Maryland 5,773,552 1.86% $348,083,923
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Wisconsin 5,686,986 1.83% $342,864,912
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Minnesota 5,303,925 1.71% $319,770,398
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Colorado 5,029,196 1.62% $303,207,154
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Alabama 4,779,736 1.54% $288,167,363
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
South Carolina 4,625,364 1.49% $278,860,370
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Louisiana 4,533,372 1.46% $273,314,228
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Kentucky 4,339,367 1.40% $261,617,785
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Oregon 3,831,074 1.23% $230,973,111
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Oklahoma 3,751,351 1.21% $226,166,660
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Connecticut 3,574,097 1.15% $215,480,125
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Iowa 3,046,355 0.98% $183,662,882
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Mississippi 2,967,297 0.95% $178,896,523
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Arkansas 2,915,918 0.94% $175,798,915
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Kansas 2,853,118 0.92% $172,012,741
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Utah 2,763,885 0.89% $166,632,938
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Nevada 2,700,551 0.87% $162,814,570
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
New Mexico 2,059,179 0.66% $124,146,644
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
West Virginia 1,852,994 0.60% $111,715,876
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Nebraska 1,826,341 0.59% $110,108,983
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Idaho 1,567,582 0.50% $94,508,561
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Hawaii 1,360,301 0.44% $82,011,716
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Maine 1,328,361 0.43% $80,086,073
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
New Hampshire 1,316,470 0.42% $79,369,172
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Rhode Island 1,052,567 0.34% $63,458,621
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Montana 989,415 0.32% $59,651,226
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Delaware 897,934 0.29% $54,135,892
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
South Dakota 814,180 0.26% $49,086,415
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Alaska 710,231 0.23% $42,819,393
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
North Dakota 672,591 0.22% $40,550,100
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Vermont 625,741 0.20% $37,725,543
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
District of Columbia 601,723 0.19% $36,277,512
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Wyoming 563,626 0.18% $33,980,667
Top 10 Metropolitan Areas
Metro Market Population Percentage Burden of the Ban
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
New York-Northern NJ-Long Island, NY-NJ-PA 18,897,109 6.08% $1,139,295,157
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Los Angeles-Long Beach-Santa Ana, CA 12,828,837 4.13% $773,442,745
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Chicago-Joliet-Naperville, IL-IN-WI 9,461,105 3.04% $570,404,240
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Dallas-Fort Worth-Arlington, TX 6,371,773 2.05% $384,150,301
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Philadelphia-Camden-Wilmington, PA-NJ-DE-MD 6,230,000 2.00% $375,602,894
Houston-Sugar Land-Baytown, TX 5,946,800 1.91% $358,528,939
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Washington-Arlington-Alexandria, DC-VA-MD-WV 5,582,170 1.79% $336,545,619
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Miami-Fort Lauderdale-Pompano Beach, FL 5,564,635 1.79% $335,488,445
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Atlanta-Sandy Springs-Marietta, GA 5,268,860 1.69% $317,656,350
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Boston-Cambridge-Quincy, MA-NH 4,552,402 1.46% $274,461,535

 

Independence LED has provided this content as a convenience to the members of our Authorized Reseller Network to help clarify the details in speaking with civic leaders and business owners and operators about the ban on T12 fluorescent tubes that started on June 14th, 2012.

See CASH for CLUNKERS Lighting  for information on the multi-million dollar incentive program.

Independence LED www.IndependenceLED.com is a U.S. Manufacturer of high-efficiency linear LED lighting. Since moving its manufacturing from China to Boyertown, PA, Independence LED has experienced over 300% growth in sales.  Customers range from industrial distribution centers to Fortune 100 companies and from independent business owners to national retail and service chains. In 2011, the Company won the Green Business of the Year Award from the Main Line Chamber of Commerce.  For Technology, Photos, and Videos see the Independence LED Boot Camp.

The IMPACT and OPPORTUNITY from the DOE Ban on Inefficient T2 Fluorescent Tubes

A major change in the rules for lighting technology will directly affect many commercial and industrial businesses and institutions in the United States.  If you have the older, T12 fluorescent tubes in your workplace, you have just 30 days to prepare for this fundamental change as T12 fluorescent tubes will no longer be manufactured in the United States or imported from offshore manufacturers. The DOE estimates there are almost 1 billion T12 fluorescent tubes currently operating in America’s building infrastructure.

T12s waste energy, create toxic mercury & PCB’s in their waste stream, provide poor quality light and have very high operational costs. Independence LED Tubes are three times more energy efficient and last three times longer. International powerhouse brands have made these Fluorescent T12 Clunkers for years, and since lighting is not separated out on electric bills, the wasted energy has gone largely undetected for decades. The major brands now offer more efficient T8 and T5 Fluorescent Tubes and “eco ballasts”, but these alternative fluorescent options still use about twice as much energy as the LEDs, have a shorter life and require the purchase of new ballasts, adapters or completely new fixtures. To learn more about the value of switching directly to LED linear lighting, read our White Paper: The T12 Fluorescent to LED Tube Retrofit Advantage

Independence LED Lighting is offering U.S. business owners coverage on the cost of proper disposal and recycling of their existing T12 fluorescent “Clunkers” and ballasts as an offset to the purchase price of American Made Independence LED Tubes. T’12’s have mercury and their ballasts have PCB’s which are harmful to the environment and must be processed according to strict Federal and State regulations. The program is capped at $10 Million in “Cash” offsets.

Creating Jobs this Summer and Saving Businesses Millions of Dollars.

President Obama has reached a key understanding. On December 2nd, 2011, the President wrote a Memorandum, “Upgrading the energy performance of buildings is one of the fastest and most effective ways to reduce energy costs, cut pollution, and create jobs in the construction and energy sectors.”

See the full White House Memorandum Dec 2011.

Why Act Now?

LOOK UP. If you are at work, outside of a home office, you probably will see fluorescent tubes that have dominated commercial lighting since the 1950s. The T12 fluorescent are the older style wide tubes that are about an inch and half in diameter. T12s are “Clunkers” in that they waste energy and have toxic mercury vapor. The common 4’ Tube uses 45 Watts with the ballast factor compared to a 15 Watt LED Tube. The T12s also die off within 20,000 vs the 60,000 hour life of the LED Tubes. Replacing them creates jobs…NOW. The jobs range from Energy Auditing to Installation and from production of replacement products like U.S. Made of LED tubes to the “Ripple Effect” of the entire supply and delivery chain. See the ‘MADE In AMERICA Panel’ for a breakdown of the job creation opportunity. Given that the T12 ban is on almost 1 billion tubes, this is a potential employment launch pad for the American Energy Revolution.

How Many T12s are out there?

Page #35 of the Department of Energy DOE January 2012 Report identifies:

2,385,399,000 fluorescent tubes in American ceilings:

48.1%: T8s totaling 1,148,222,000 Tubes

39.5%: T12s totaling 941,335,000 Tubes

12.4%: T5s or Miscellaneous totaling 295,842,000 Tubes

With almost 1 billion Clunker T12 fluorescent tubes in American ceilings, the hunt is on to reduce waste!

This is a dramatic eye opener, and for perspective imagine if 40% of the cars on the road got less than 10 miles per gallon or had an equivalent emissions rating from the 1970s today.

Why is it such a Big Deal?

According to the DOE, over half of our U.S. electricity consumption is for buildings. Plus, lighting accounts for 30% -35% of all commercial electricity use, per the Electric Power Research Institute. See the EPRI Report.

The ban will cost $18.75 Billion:

For the common 4’ length, each legal T8 fluorescent replacement tube is $2 to $3, but the old T12 ballasts need to be replaced to match the new tubes. The legal ballasts are $10 to $15, and they can run two tubes. The equipment burden averages to $8.75 per tube. With ten minutes of wiring installation, the labor burden averages $10 per tube. With about 1 billion T12 tubes, per DOE data included in the T12 White Paper, the burden of the ban reaches $18.75 billion – a tough challenge in a recession.

4’ T12 Fluorescent to 4’ LED Tube Retrofits:

Sample Scenario with an Electricity Cost of $.10 per kWh and run time of 24/7:

This would mean that Parking Garage LED tubes, Exit Stair LED tubes, Hallway LED tubes, or Warehouse LED tubes, could each save $26.28 per year over a T12. This savings comes from taking the Annual $39.42 Cost to Operate a Single 4’ T12 45 Watt Tube and subtracting the 4’ LED 15 Watt tube which only uses $13.41 of electricity per year. By comparison at $.20 / kWh, the annual Cost to Operate a Single 4’ T12 45 Watt Tube is $78.84, while the 15 Watts LED Tube only costs $26.28 to operate per year. This yields a savings of Savings of $52.56 per LED Tube retrofit.

Example of New York City Rebates:

Utility – Con Edison for qualified LED Tubes like the Independence LED ‘Eagle” series.

Rebate on Annual kWh Saved:  $.13 for 24/7 operations: Rebate Calculation: T12 45 Watts to LED 15 Watts = 30 Watts Saved x 8,760 Annual Hours /1,000 = 262.8 Annual kWh Saved. 262.8 Annual kWh x $.13 = REBATE: $34.16. T12 LED Rebates are an excellent way for New York City Property Owners and Managers to make the retrofit of LED Lighting more affordable.  For 8’ Tubes the savings and rebates almost double!

Highlights on the Energy Policy Act and DOE Fact Sheet

The AMENDMENTS to the Energy Policy Act of 1992 include SEC. 123 which identifies the Energy Conservation Requirements for Certain Lamps. Given the complexity of the Amendments, the March 23, 2011 FACT SHEET released by the DOE identifies the Impact of the Amended Energy Conservation Standards on General Service Fluorescent Lamps.

These amended standards have a compliance date of July 14, 2012 for manufacturers or importers of covered general service fluorescent lamps.”

The DOE goes on to explain, “The amended energy conservation standards, which are performancebased, do not explicitly prohibit the sale of T12 diameter lamps. Based on DOE’s analysis, however, most commercially-available T12 lamps are too inefficient to meet the amended standards and can no longer be manufactured for distribution in commerce after July 14, 2012. The DOE also recognizes that the ballast factor is a key cost and, “if a consumer replaces an existing T12 system with a more-efficient T8 or T5 diameter system, he or she may need to purchase a new ballast or fixture.”

The cost of new fluorescent tubes and new ballasts along with the associated labor costs compound to serves as a key financial driver to retrofit with efficient LED Tubes. This approach to leapfrog over the slightly better fluorescent options delivers savings in excess of 50%.

Each of the following general service fluorescent lamps and incandescent reflector lamps

manufactured after the effective date specified in the tables listed in this paragraph shall meet or exceed the following lamp efficacy and CRI standards:

Lamp type; Nominal lamp wattage; Minimum CRI; Minimum average lamp efficacy in Lumens per Watt

 

2-foot U-shaped;  >35W; 69 CRI;  68 lm/W

2-foot U-shaped; ≤35W; 45 CRI; 64 lm/W

 

4-foot medium bipin; >35W; 69 CRI; 75 lm/W

4-foot medium bipin; ≤35W; 45 CRI; 75 lm/W

 

8-foot slimline; >65W; 69 CRI; 80 lm/W

8-foot slimline; ≤65W; 45 CRI; 80 lm/W

8-foot high output; >100W; 69 CRI; 80 lm/W

8-foot high output; ≤100W; 45 CRI; 80 lm/W